| Football Season | Homecoming Queen (maiden name) |
| 1955 | Deanne Weigle |
| 1956 | Louise Backus |
| 1957 | Pat Rahrig |
| 1958 | Diane Kundert |
| 1959 | Therese Kimmet |
| 1960 | Virginia Osting |
| 1961 | Nadine Van Schoyck |
| 1962 | Mary Lou Kill |
| 1963 | Pam Hanser |
| 1964 | Kathleen Hollar |
| 1965 | Sarah Clark |
| 1966 | Janet Brandehoff |
| 1967 | Elaine Grubenhoff |
| 1968 | Corinne Klausing |
| 1969 | Susan Pothast |
| 1970 | Connie Pohlman |
| 1971 | Sue Clark |
| 1972 | Mary Ann Suever |
| 1973 | Robin Obermeyer |
| 1974 | Deb Plumpe |
| 1975 | Kim Nichols |
| 1976 | Cindy Grothous |
| 1977 | Tina Flanagan |
| 1978 | Donna Hirn |
| 1979 | Ann Pohlman |
| 1980 | Sue Youngpeter |
| 1981 | Deb Wagner |
| 1982 | Deanne Kaverman |
| 1983 | Lanna Smith |
| 1984 | Michelle Wurst |
| 1985 | Lorie Harpster |
| 1986 | Jennifer Knebel |
| 1987 | Kelly Alder |
| 1988 | Anne Hohman |
| 1989 | Corey Westrich |
| 1990 | Jenni Fischer |
| 1991 | Kerri Wannemacher |
| 1992 | Lisa Clark |
| 1993 | Laura Langhals |
| 1994 | Marcie Gilles |
| 1995 | Sara Suever |
| 1996 | Tina Reindel |
| 1997 | Chris Altenburger |
| 1998 | Stephanie Mansfield |
| 1999 | Allison Suever |
| 2000 | Amie Wiechart |
| 2001 | Jamie Bergfeld |
| 2002 | Ashley Baldauf |
| 2003 | Julie Bergfeld |
| 2004 | Kyla Hershey |
| 2005 | Alyssa Klausing - Last Year with Red Robe |
| 2006 | Lauren Etzkorn - First Year with Blue Robe |
| 2007 | Katie Grothouse |
| 2008 | Lauren Klausing |
| 2009 | Lyndsie Reindel |
| 2010 | Alicia Ankerman
|
| 2011 | Kaitlyn Wrasman |
| 2012 | Katrina Etzkorn |
| 2013 | Jessica Koverman |
| 2014 | Alyssa Martin |
| 2015 | Lexie Hays |
| 2016 | Jessica Geise |
| 2017 | Jessica Odenweller |
| 2018 | Josie Schulte |
| 2019 | Aubrie Friemoth |
| 2020 | Addison Mueller |
| 2021 | Abigail Shafer |