| 1921 | How the Story Grows | |
| | | |
| 1924 | Pontia the Daughter of Pilate | |
| 1925 | This Was an Allegory | |
| 1929 | Withered Flowers | |
| 1931 | Cyclone Sally | |
| 1932 | Apple Fritters | |
| 1933 | The Whoffenproof Operetta "The Sunbonnet Girl" | |
| 1934 | Blind Date | |
| 1935 | Shirt Sleeves | |
| 1936 | New Fires | |
| 1937 | Oh, Doctor | |
| 1938 | Balmy Days | |
| 1939 | Man or Mouse | |
| 1940 | Who Wouldn't Be Crazy | |
| 1941 | Night of January 16th | |
| 1942 | Father Malachey's Miracle | |
| 1943 | Our Town | |
| 1944 | Convent on the Cliff | |
| 1945 | Dark Town Jamboree | |
| 1946 | Gay Nineties | |
| 1947 | Little Nellie Kelly | |
| 1948 | Rio Rita | |
| 1949 | Captain Lee's Showboat | |
| 1950 | Swing Out Sweet Land | |
| 1951 | Oklahoma (Green Grow the Lilacs) | |
| 1952 | Brigadoon | |
| 1953 | Little Nellie Kelly | |
| 1954 | Rose Marie | |
| 1955 | Seventeen | |
| 1956 | Annie Get Your Gun | |
| 1957 | Show Boat | |
| 1958 | Babes in Toyland | |
| 1959 | Boy Friend | |
| 1960 | Mississippi Melody | |
| 1961 | The King & I | Directed by Father Kuhn |
| 1962 | Around the World in Eighty Days | Directed by Father Kuhn |
| 1963 | Bye Bye Birdie | Directed by Father Kuhn |
| 1964 | The Unsinkable Molly Brown | Directed by Father Kuhn |
| 1965 | The Sound of Music | Directed by Father Kuhn |
| | SENIOR CLASS PLAYS DIRECTED BY JOHN GUNDER | DIRECTOR'S AWARD |
| 1966 | Carousel | None |
| 1967 | Oklahoma | None |
| 1968 | Oliver | None |
| 1969 | South Pacific | Craig McRedmond |
| 1970 | Mame | Sue Huysman |
| 1971 | Guys & Dolls | Maureen Kaskel |
| 1972 | Anything Goes | Joe Pohlman |
| 1973 | Girl Crazy | Cindy Brandehoff |
| 1974 | West Side Story | Lisa Hanshumaker |
| 1975 | Bye Bye Birdie | Mary Grothouse |
| 1976 | Pajama Game | Phil Noonan |
| 1977 | Damn Yankee | Tom Merschman |
| 1978 | Brigadoon | Angela Klima |
| 1979 | Flower Drum Song | Joan Berelsman |
| 1980 | Sweet Charity | Sue Rahrig |
| 1981 | Applause | Jeff Noonan |
| 1982 | Bring Back Birdie | Cheryl Wellman |
| 1983 | The Wiz | Beth Kaskel |
| 1984 | Shenandoah | Scott Wellman |
| 1985 | Gigi | Jim Hoffman |
| 1986 | The Music Man | Donnie Ditto |
| 1987 | The Sound of Music | Scott Knebel |
| 1988 | 42nd Street | Travis Roxlau |
| 1989 | My One & Only | Doug Etgen |
| 1990 | Bells are Ringing | Craig Ebbeskotte |
| 1991 | Fantastiks | Kelly Schroeder |
| 1992 | Seven Brides for Seven Brothers | Nicki Wienken |
| 1993 | Camelot | Kevin Schimmoeller |
| 1994 | Meet Me in St. Louis | Bob Grone |
| 1995 | Godspell | Tricia Elwer |
| 1996 | Li'L Abner | Nick Pohlman |
| 1997 | Fiddler on the Roof | Dan Kapcar |
| 1998 | Cinderella | Gina Gerdeman |
| 1999 | Babes in Arms | Ali Schmit |
| 2000 | Grease | Nate Stant |
| 2001 | Nunsense | Allison Alt, Erin Smith, Gina Ulm, Ashley Kreidler, & Melissa Wieman |
| 2002 | Hello Dolly | Nick Massa |
| 2003 | You're a Good Man Charlie Brown | Jacob Schuck |
| 2004 | Children of Eden | Chris Grote |
| 2005 | A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum | Zach Mauk, Nate Scherger |
| | ALL SCHOOL PLAYS DIRECTED BY SUSIE SLAWINSKI | DIRECTOR'S AWARD |
| 2006 | Cinderella | Julia Pohlman |
| 2007 | Seussical | The Entire Cast (*This was the year I was in the hospital & Mrs. Honingford & the kids did an amazing job of keeping things together without me there. I would email Kim all my notes for rehearsal everyday & she & the kids forged ahead! It was a tough show & they did an amazing job of keeping it together) *From Susie |
| 2008 | Little Women | Clarissa Schnipke, Rachel Osting |
| 2009 | Honk | Lauren Klausing, Emily Stant, Trevor Kroeger |
| 2010 | Bye Bye Birdie | Katie Honingford, Tyler Koester, Trevor Kroeger, Torii Rutledge |
| 2011 | Oklahoma | Trevor Kroeger, Kathleen Wreede |
| 2012 | Snoopy! | Nathan Pohlman, Katie Honingford, Kathleen Wreede, Calvin Vonderwell, Megan Joseph, Brendan Giambruno-
Fuge |
| 2013 | Once Upon A Mattress | Calvin Vonderwell, Megan Joseph |
| 2014 | Godspell | Patrick Stevenson |
| 2015 | Guys and Dolls | Jared Honigford, Samantha Wehri, Aaron Schnipke, Colleen Schulte, Patrick Stevenson |
| 2016 | Footloose | Jared Honigford, Patrick Stevenson, Aaron Schnipke
|
| 2017 | Seussical | Haley Rode, Alexis Deffenbaugh, Aaron Schnipke, Patrick Stevenson
|
| 2018 | Into the Woods | Caroline Kopack, Abra Riley, Adam Schneer
|
| 2019 | The Little Mermaid | Caroline Kopack, Abra Riley, Marcus Freewalt
|
| 2020 | Oliver! | (Sadly, our cast was unable to perform due to the COVID-19 pandemic |
| 2021 | Broadway Then and Now-A Musical Revue | Ryan Stricker, Abra Riley
|
| 2022 | "Shrek the Musical TYA!"
| Nicole Pohlman, Marcus Freewalt
|
| 2023 | Grease | Melanie Mueller, Noah Slawinski
|
| 2024 | Into the Woods | Beth Garrett, Tess Vonderwell
|